Evidence ยท School closures
How long were schools closed during COVID?
What the data shows about how long American children were out of the classroom in 2020 and 2021, with a link to every source.
The short answer
It depended on where you lived. Every state closed schools in spring 2020, and 48 kept them closed for the rest of that school year. In the fall of 2020, more than 60% of US students started the year in virtual-only schools, and by January 2021 that share was still 55%. How long a child stayed out of the classroom depended on the state and the district.
Spring 2020: every state closed schools
All 50 states closed schools to in-person instruction in spring 2020, and 48 kept them closed for the rest of the academic year, according to Ballotpedia.
2020-21: most students began the year remote
Burbio, which tracked district reopening plans, found that in early September 2020 more than 60% of US students attended virtual-only schools and 18% attended traditional in-person schools. By January 2021, 55% were still virtual-only. Read the Burbio tracker.
An NBER working paper found a similar split. In fall 2020, 57% of students in district public schools had remote-only instruction, 24% had in-person instruction and 19% had hybrid instruction. Read the NBER paper.
Access varied by state
Burbio data analyzed by The 74 showed that states that voted for Donald Trump in 2020 held class in person 74.5% of the time, compared with 37.6% in states that voted for Joe Biden. That gap came to an estimated 66 more days of in-person school in the Trump-voting states.
What it cost
Researchers at Harvard and Stanford found that learning losses were larger in districts that stayed remote or hybrid longer. Brown economist Emily Oster and her team found that mostly virtual schools saw larger drops in reading and math proficiency than mostly in-person schools.
What the data does not show
Harvard economist Thomas Kane said that closures played a role in the losses but were not the primary driver of achievement differences between districts nationally.
The film
The documentary 15 DAYS tells how "15 days to flatten the curve" became 500+ days of closed schools.
Watch
Dr. Tracy Beth Hรธeg, physician and epidemiologist, on what the evidence showed about closing schools.
Journalist David Zweig on how school policy failed to follow the evidence.
What you can do now
- Watch 15 DAYS, our documentary on America's pandemic school closures.
- Read why schools stayed closed and what the research found about opening.
- Ask your school board for its written plan for the next emergency: who decides whether schools close, on what evidence, and how quickly they reopen.
- Read our page on what children lost when schools closed.
- Subscribe to our Substack for new evidence and films.
- Shop our books for children and families.
Related
We update this page as new data comes out. If you see an error, please contact us.